Here comes yet another episode of the “Comparative Overview-Series“, bringing you side-by-side in-depth comparisons of pens that you likely would like to just see like that: side-by-side.

The episode right here does focus on two Japanese classics from Pilot’s Custom line. On the one hand we have the Pilot Custom 823 – the heavyweight of the two, both literally and figuratively. A substantial vacuum-filling pen with a warm brown resin body, gold trim, and a 14k gold nib that means serious business. On the other hand we have the Pilot Custom 74 – the leaner, lighter sibling. A cartridge/converter pen in black resin with rhodium trim that has quietly earned a devoted following for its understated reliability.

Both pens share the same Custom DNA: smooth Japanese 14k gold nibs, quality resin bodies, and that distinctly Pilot balance between restraint and refinement. But beyond those shared roots, they sit quite far apart in terms of filling system, weight, size, and price. How do they stack up when placed side by side? Check out the video review below!

Before we hop into the review, I would like to take the opportunity to thank Fontoplumo for supporting the review of these pens. You can also buy the Pilot Custom 823 and the Pilot Custom 74 in their webshop (no affiliate – just a friendly pointer).

Check out the video-review below, which is as always preceded by some quick facts. Again, I hope the review is helpful and that you enjoy watching it!

Quick Facts

Pilot Custom 823 (Brown) & Pilot Custom 74 (Black)
Custom 823: brown resin, gold-coated trim, vacuum-filling system, 14k gold nib (includes a bottle of Pilot black ink)
Custom 74: black resin, rhodium trim, cartridge/converter filling system (converter included), 14k gold nib
Available nib options (both): Fine (F), Medium (M), Broad (B)
Price: Custom 823 ca. 375 € / Custom 74 ca. 200 €