Lefties, Ink, and Fountain Pens
Why is there a need for an explanation of the format of an ink-review, you might ask?! Well, because the ink reviews on Scrively are not like all the other ink reviews that you will find out there. This, again, is because Scrively is written by a lefty. Hence, I have walked that extra mile and made the effort to come up with a slightly twisted own format for ink reviewing that aims at catering my needs – and hopefully the needs of many more southpaws out there. It is my sincere hope that I will be able to serve the lefty-fountain pen community with ink-reviews that are meaningful – in the hope for ever more lefties to start daring to pick up a fountain pen and also experience the joy of writing with fountain pens, which really is a pleasure indeed. Of course, I do also hope that the reviews are enjoyable to the ‘right’-handed fellows out there, too 🙂 .
So what is special about the ink reviews here on Scrively?
Well, lefties sometimes (think they) have a fountain pen issue, because the writing from left to right causes the writing hand to slide over what has just been written (the “writing line”), thus smudging and smearing the fresh, wet ink all over the place. This writing style is called side-writing and is the way most lefties, unless they’ve retrained themselves, tend to write. This includes myself as well.
Now there are a lot many well-meant tips out there on the internet on how, as a lefty, you might succeed in retraining your writing style so as to be able to write as if you basically were right-handed. Underwriting, for instance, is one of those “strategies” which are considered to be very effective, because this technique will keep your writing-hand below the writing line. With that, you will most likely have next to zero restrictions when it comes to fountain pen writing, i.e. you will be able to use all the nibs (flex, broad…anything that puts a lot of ink on the paper and, in turn, will take an eternity to dry), inks (no need for caring about drying times), and paper (so called fountain pen-friendly paper which is quite “ink resistant” and causes the ink to dry slowly – that helps the ink to develop more…let’s just call it “character” here) that right handed people can use, too. Sounds great, doesn’t it?
No, it doesn’t. At least not to me. Why? Personally, I tried to practice underwriting for a little while. Not more than some days, though. So yeah, technically, I can absolutely see this working. No doubt. However, I just refuse to strain and twist my wrist and joints into the most uncomfortable of positions for weeks or months, just to become sort of something I am not – a wannabe righty. To me, a writing-tool has to accommodate my needs, not the other way around.
On top of that, all this effort and stress of retraining your writing habits, at least in my own experience, is absolutely not necessary. That is, if you just consider a few things, that really ain’t a big deal: you just combine the right nib-sizes, paper-choice and ink. That might sound complicated, but really isn’t at all. In short, with nibs you stick with EF to M. With paper, you just refrain from the super-duper fountain pen-paper, that will have that ink laying on it’s surface for ages to show all that shading. Taking that into consideration, you are all set to become a very happy fountain pen user.
Disclaimer: Provided you have an approach that is similar to mine, i.e. you are more of a functional writer with a great appreciation for the aesthetics of writing (paper, pen & ink) while not being overambitious with artistic writing or calligraphy or a longing for thick strokes, a lot of line variation (i.e. flex nibs), very wet nibs/inks or paper that brings the best details out of an ink. Then you might really have to become an underwriter. Personally, I am more than good with a regular line and seeing at least most of the nice characteristics of the ink I use.
Having that said as a rather long prelude, let’s now turn to the format that I came up with and that I do employ for all of my ink reviews.
The Lefty-Ink Review Format
As a lefty, I will do most ink reviews using EF- to M- nibs. These do not lay down too much ink on the paper. The ink will then, of course, dry much faster than with a broader nib, which is what the typical lefty might want in everyday pen usage. Hence, I am mostly interested in how the ink performs and what the ink looks like (ink characteristics) using any of those nib-sizes. This also means that I am not using any flex- or whatever-nibs in my reviews, since I do (for now) simply not care how an ink behaves or looks with those ones. Since I am, of course, nevertheless interested in what the color (and some shading) really looks like on paper, each ink review will contain an ink swab.
On top of that, I will place special emphasis on the wetness and the drying times of the ink which, again, is of special interest to lefties. Besides the drying time, I came up with something that – besides the “Regular Smear Test“ – I call the “Left-Page Smear Test”. First of all, I do write with all the inks that I test for about one week, using them as my everyday ink for this period of time. This is the amount of time where I can really see how the ink performs in various conditions and where I will also fill a couple of pages in my notebooks. The “Regular Smear Test” then just comments on the “smeariness” (is that a word even?) of the ink that one would experience when actually writing “regularly”. The “Left-Page Smear Test” responds to the fact that, as a lefty, when writing on the right page of a notebook, your writing hand will rest (for longer periods of time) on the left page of the notebook. The ink on that left page is already dry, but the extended resting of the palm on that dry ink will occasionally cause smudging. And this is what the “Left-Page Smear Test” is all about: Will the dry ink on the left page smudge?
When it comes to the “testing ground”, which is the paper on which I test, I will always test on two types of paper: Leuchtturm 1917 and a regular standard spiral bound notepad. Why?
For the Leuchtturm 1917, this is one of my (and many other people’s) preferred notebook. First of all, Leuchtturm is for many reasons among the favorite notebook options for many Bullet Journalists, which I am one of. Second, the paper is quite fountain pen friendly and lefty friendly. This means that it is just ink resistant enough to show you some of the nicer ink characteristics such as shading, while it is also just absorbent enough to make it the perfect choice for lefties. On top of that, the paper is slightly off-white or ivory, as are many notebooks out there, so you will be able to see what the ink looks like on such a paper.
For the standard spiral bound notepad: this is still the default paper in many peoples daily lives around the world. Not everybody will want to spend a premium on high quality notebooks, or use such notebooks for all kinds of writing. The spiral bound notepad (“Collegeblock”) is widely available in any stationery store or even supermarket, and often the go-to notepad for studies or work, since one can tear out and easily file the pages. Most of those spiral bound notepads are rather okay to write on with fountain pens. They are better than standard copy paper (i.e. the one used in printers, which is not really meant to write on with fountain pens), but not as good as the rather premium notebooks. Sometimes, notepad paper is a more absorbent than the better notebooks, which makes it a good option for many lefties, because the ink basically dries – or rather: gets absorbed – a bit faster. On top of that, I use this paper as a reference so as to see what the ink looks like on white paper.
Having that said, I do not test ink on e.g. Tomoe River or Clairefontaine paper, because I and many other lefties do not write on such a kind of paper. For the interested reader, ink reviews on such paper are widely available in other corners of the web, where my ‘right’-handed fellows do an excellent job in reviewing ink.
So, in short, the ink reviews on Scrively follow the scheme below:
Review criteria
- Testing time is always 1 week (or more)
- Unit capacity (ml) and price (€)
- Price per milliliter (€ / ml)
- Color and saturation
- Shading
- Feathering
- Bleed-through
- Appeared wetness
- Drying time
- Smudging/Smear when dry: deliberately smearing with a finger across dry ink
- Smudging-/Smear-Test
- “Regular Smear Test“: Smeariness when writing “regularly”
- “Left-Page Smear Test”: Tendency to smudge once being dry for an extended period of time – i.e. the fact that, as a lefty, when writing on the right page of a notebook, the writing hand will rest (for longer periods of time) on the left page of the notebook. The ink on that left page is already dry, but the extended resting of the palm on that dry ink will occasionally cause smudging. This test checks, if the ink smudges under those circumstances, or not.
- Reviews will always encompass an ink-swab and a writing sample with anything from EF- to M-nibs
Testing ground
- Standard Spiral Bound Notepad, white paper, 80 gsm
- Leuchtturm 1917-notebook, off-white/ivory paper, 80 gsm
Lefty-Rating
For providing accuracy and consistency when it comes to the representation of the ink’s color, all scans of my ink reviews are produced with a Doxie Flip mobile scanner @600 dpi.
I sincerely hope that this section will be helpful to you and that you enjoy reading it!
Kaweco “Smokey Grey”: a interesting grey with great shading
Ink name: Kaweco “Smokey Grey”
Unit capacity: 30 ml (glas bottle)
Price: 10 €
Price per ml: ca. 0,33 €
| Leuchtturm 1917 | Spiral-bound Notepad | |
| Color | Normally a lighter stone-grey with a greenish hue | Stone-grey with a greenish hue |
| Saturation | Medium | Medium |
| Shading | Amazing shading. The nib used in the review is pretty wet, causing the ink to poole often. When I go slow with writing and the nib lays down a lot of ink, the color gets dark to an almost graphite-black | Very interesting shading – very pronounced |
| Feathering | None | None |
| Bleed-through | None | A little on the 2nd pass (but note: the nib used here is very wet!) |
| Wetness | Rather wet | Rather wet |
| Drying time | ca. 8-10 sec. (NB: Very wet nib used – so should come down by about 2 sec. with a drier nib) | ca. 5 sec. (NB: Very wet nib used – so should come down by about 2 sec. with a drier nib) |
| Smudging when dry | No | No |
| Regular smear test | Ok | Ok |
| Left-page smear test | Ok | – |
Handwritten review on Leuchtturm 1917 paper
(scanned @600 dpi with Doxie Flip – click image to enlarge on Flickr)
Handwritten review on a Standard Spiral-Bound Notepad
(scanned @600 dpi with Doxie Flip – click image to enlarge on Flickr)
Kaweco has recently released two new ink colors to add to the lineup of the already existing eight colors. The two new colors are “Sunrise Orange” and “Smokey Grey”. While the latter will be reviewed here, the inks are not yet widely available at the time of writing this review. Most likely, the distribution is still ongoing – but the inks should be available soon.
“Smokey Grey” is a really interesting ink. Colorwise, it is quite a lot lighter than the recently reviewed Diamine Grey, for instance. I would say that it is a stone grey tone with some greenish hues to it. However, the shading of the ink really sort of makes the name “smokey grey” appropriate. Just as smoke can be very light at its thinner parts and almost black where it is fairly dense, the same can be said for this ink.
The maybe truest representation of the inks color are the ink-swatches in the handwritten reviews as well as the bottle-label (see the header photo), which also does a pretty good job in giving an idea of the ink’s color. Note that especially in the handwritten review on the Leuchtturm-paper, the first few lines when the fountain pen just had been uncapped and layed down a very wet line of ink, the color gets even graphite-blackish. The spectrum in between that and the ink swatches sort of shows the inks shading-ability, which I find extraordinary. Especially with a very wet nib like the Jowo-Medium nib that is mounted to the Diplomat Aero that I wrote the review with (I will have a review of this pen coming in about 4 weeks Edit: review is done and now linked).
Otherwise, Kaweco “Smokey Grey” is a very well behaved ink that is on the wetter side – but dries fast. I find it a fun ink that is good when you are tired of blue or black inks.
Pricewise, I do find the Kaweco ink fairly expensive. With around 0,30€/ml it is in direct competition with luxury inks such as the Graf von Faber-Castell inks, Pelikans Edelstein Ink-series or the Pilot Iroshizuku inks. A Diamine ink, for instance, costs about a third of that (roughly 0,11€/ml). While the Kaweco ink is certainly a great ink, no doubt here, I think it would be of great help to for example also make the packaging match its price. While the luxury inks mentioned above all come in very elaborate design glas flacons, the Kaweco ink comes in a simple bottle that you for example also find with the Pelikan 4001 inks – the latter also costing less than half of the Kaweco ink. On top of that, the cap of the Kaweco-bottle does not close perfectly. The inner white plastic lid-inlay often sort of comes off when opening the bottle and/or makes it difficult to close the bottle with the lid sitting on the bottleneck with an all-around even gap. While this is not a huge issue, it certainly counts considering the price of the ink. Having that said, I would either lower the price of the ink or increase the whole appearance. Again, the ink itself is really good – no complaints here.
As for its ‘leftyness’, “Smokey Grey” is a very good ink, too. Being a fairly wet ink, it still dries very fast, even with a super wet nib like the one that I wrote the handwritten review with. So, with a ‘more normal’ nib, you could expect drying times of about -2 sec. of what has been stated in the table above. Also, there is next to no chance that the ink smudges once dry. This all makes it excellent for lefties and one of my to-go greys for the future!
Lefty approved? Yes. No doubt about that!
I hope this ink review was helpful – feel free to check out my other ink reviews as well.
If you would like to compare this color to any other ink color/brand, I would suggest to head over to GouletPen’s “Interactive SwabShop” – a tool that lets you compare over 500 different inks, while the swabs are done under similar conditions. This is a wonderful tool for “cross-color-brand-comparison” that I can highly recommend.
Fantastic review, thank you.
Thank you so much for taking the time to leave a comment. I really do appreciate this kind of feedback! Thanks, and thanks again!
Agreed, Kaweco must invest a little more on their ink bottles and packaging if they want to go head to head with the likes of Pelikan and Iroshizuku. But still then, I find the Edelstein lineup to perform better than the couple of colors I’ve tried from Kaweco. Their Paradise Blue ink is the only ink I own that dries in the pen if not used for a couple or more days.
Excellent review and gorgeous site. Instant fan!
Hi Guillermo! Thanks a lot for your thoughtful comment!
Also, I would wanna agree with you. What I meant was that Kaweco, price wise, puts themselves head to head into competition with the likes of Edelstein, Faber Castell, and Iroshizuku – but then the overall appearance does not live up to that. That is the packaging, of course, but also, as you said, the ink itself. I do also find Edelstein (as well as Iroshizuku) to be better performing inks. I never had any issues with the Kaweco inks drying up in a pen. I do also like the colors a lot. Most of them are pretty deep and saturated. The problem, however, (especially for a lefty) is that most of the Kaweco inks are prone to smudgeing after they had tried. For a lefty, that is not very good. I have a couple more reviews of some of their inks coming over the next months, I hope. Just didn’t get around to them yet. The grey is indeed my favorite of all their inks. I currently have sunrise orange inked, and this will be the next to be reviewed.
Thanks again for your kind words!
I’m also a leftie but am not having smudging issues with the Kaweco yet -tell you, this ink is pretty dry. Thou, thanks to your review, I will definitely be biting the bullet again with that gorgeous Grey from Kaweco!
I never tried the paradise blue. Smudging occurs with me especially with the Royal Blue, Pearl Black, and Caramel Brown. The Grey and Orange are fine, though. Bet you will like the Grey!